The Best: Ice Cream

Nothing says summer like a perfect scoop of ice cream. In today’s edition of The Best, we’ve tasted, tested, and researched our way through dozens of pints to bring you a curated list of the most beloved and critically acclaimed ice creams available in the U.S. From classic flavors to refined favorites, these are the must-haves for your freezer.

The Best Overall: Jeni’s Splendid Ice Cream – Brown Butter Almond Brittle

Why we love it: A cult classic with caramel-like depth and perfect crunch. Handmade with high-quality ingredients and no shortcuts.

"This is the kind of ice cream that makes you slow down and savor every bite," says Samin Nosrat, author of Salt Fat Acid Heat.

The Best Vanilla: McConnell’s Fine Ice Creams – Vanilla Bean

Why we love it: This is vanilla done properly, with cream from grass-grazed cows and pure Madagascar vanilla beans. Silky and flavorful, it's a timeless favorite.

"Vanilla is the true test of any creamery," says David Lebovitz, renowned pastry chef and author. "McConnell’s sets the bar."

The Best Pistachio: Van Leeuwen – Pistachio

Why we love it: Rich, nutty, and slightly salty, this flavor uses real roasted pistachios and delivers a refined, complex taste that's not too sweet.

"An elevated version of a nostalgic flavor, done with true elegance," notes Bon Appétit Magazine.

The Best Clean Formula: Coconut Bliss – Madagascan Vanilla Bean (Dairy-Free)

Why we love it: Organic, dairy-free, and naturally sweetened with agave, this option is beloved by those avoiding traditional ice cream but still wanting something indulgent.

The Best for Kids (Healthy Choice): GoodPop – Organic Freezer Pops

Why we love it: Made with real fruit and no artificial dyes or sugars, these kid-friendly treats are refreshing, fun, and mom-approved.

The Best Classic Chocolate: Häagen-Dazs – Chocolate Ice Cream

Why we love it: It’s rich, creamy, and undeniably chocolatey; this timeless favorite hasn’t changed for a reason. Still one of the best pints money can buy.

FAQs

What makes a high-quality ice cream?
Look for a short ingredient list with real cream, egg yolks, and natural flavorings. Premium brands often have less air (overrun), giving them a richer texture.

Is organic or dairy-free ice cream better for you?
It depends on your dietary needs. Many dairy-free or organic ice creams are lower in allergens and contain fewer additives.

Where can I find these ice creams?
Most options are available at Whole Foods, Amazon Fresh, and specialty grocery stores. Check local retailers for regional favorites.

DISCOVER THE PERFECT SERVEWARE FOR YOUR NEXT SCOOP IN OUR ENTERTAINING COLLECTION.

I AM GRATEFUL FOR TODAY:

• A perfectly cold spoonful of ice cream on a warm afternoon

• Celebrating small indulgences with loved ones

• Discovering new favorites worth sharing

REMINDERS:

• Add ice cream bowls to your summer entertaining essentials

• Keep spoons chilled for the perfect scoop

• Homemade toppings like toasted nuts or warm caramel turn good into unforgettable