The Best Butter: Luxurious Picks for Toast, Baking, and Beautiful Living

french butter, cultured butter, gourmet pantry essentials

Today we’re exploring one of life’s simplest and most sublime pleasures—butter.
A true kitchen essential, butter is so much more than a spread. The best butters transform toast, enrich pastries, elevate sauces, and add depth to the most humble vegetables. Whether salted or unsalted, cultured or sweet cream, butter—at its best—is a quiet luxury that brings daily delight.

We considered the choices of chefs, bakers, and dairy experts to select butters that balance quality, flavor, craftsmanship, and elegance. These are not just staples, they are delicacies worth savoring.

---

1. Échiré AOP Cultured Butter (France)

Best Overall: Iconic French Elegance

Why we love it:
Handcrafted in the village of Échiré using traditional methods since 1894, this butter is gently churned in wooden barrels, which gives it a delicate texture and nuanced, tangy flavor. AOC-certified and beloved by French pâtissiers and Michelin-starred chefs, Échiré is a must-have for the refined pantry.

• Available in both salted and unsalted varieties

• Comes wrapped in its signature gold foil or in charming wooden baskets

• Buttery, creamy, slightly nutty flavor profile with cultured depth

Best for: Spreading on warm baguettes, serving at the table, or baking madeleines to perfection.

---

2. Kerrygold Pure Irish Butter (Ireland)

Best Widely Available Cultured Butter

Why we love it:
Rich in color and flavor thanks to grass-fed Irish cows, Kerrygold delivers consistent quality at a very accessible price. It’s deeply creamy, slightly salty, and widely loved for both cooking and eating. Though not as delicately cultured as Échiré, it brings exceptional richness to everyday meals.

• Comes in salted and unsalted blocks

• Excellent for sautéing, scrambling, and spreading

• Readily found in most high-quality grocery stores

Best for: Families, frequent bakers, and anyone who wants beautiful butter every day.

---

3. Rodolphe Le Meunier Beurre de Baratte (France)

Best Cultured Butter for Finishing

Why we love it:
This small-batch butter from Normandy is produced by one of France’s most respected cheesemongers and affineurs. Hand-churned and shaped, it has a vibrant, slightly acidic flavor and a rich, silky texture that melts like velvet. The salted version is made with fleur de sel from Guérande.

• Comes hand-formed and paper-wrapped, often in small discs

• Ideal for finishing fish, melting over roasted vegetables, or elevating morning toast

• Harder to find, but unforgettable once tasted

Best for: Hosts, culinary purists, and those who appreciate detail and depth.

Les Prés Salés Sea Salt Butter with Fleur de Sel (France)

Best for: Refined Salty Spreaders and French Pantry Enthusiasts

Why we love it:
This artisan French butter combines sweet, creamy butterfat with delicate flakes of Fleur de Sel from Camargue—resulting in a butter that sings on warm bread. The texture is smooth and subtle, with just the right note of crunch. It’s a deeply French, deeply pleasurable pantry essential—the one I use and usually available at Whole Foods stores.

• Seasoned with one of the world’s finest sea salts

• Creamy and delicate, yet complex

• Elegant packaging and well-distributed in specialty stores

Best for: Serving with radishes, artisan baguettes, or simply on a slice of toast with coffee.

---

Honorable Mentions

• Vermont Creamery Cultured Butter (USA): American-made, slow-cultured with European-style cream.

• Plugrá European-Style Butter (USA): Higher butterfat than standard butters, excellent for baking.

• Beurre d’Isigny AOP (France): Silky, PDO-certified, and made with cream from Normandy.

---

How to Use Butter Beautifully

• Serve in a silver or ceramic butter dish with a small sea salt pinch pot

• Whip with honey, citrus zest, or herbs for elegant compound butters

• Keep unsalted for baking, and salted for finishing

• Always bring to room temperature before serving at the table

---

Reminders

• Store butter in the fridge, but allow it to soften before use

• Wrap tightly to avoid absorbing fridge odors
  

• Cultured butter = more complex, tangy flavor—worth seeking out

---

I Am Grateful for Today

• A golden pat melting into morning toast

• The aroma of butter in a warm skillet

• The comfort of something simple, done beautifully

From Our House to Yours,
Mrs. Mayfair